The Best HP Lovecraft Books That’ll Give You Nightmares

376 Shares

You won’t have to venture far into classic horror literature to hear the name Howard Phillips Lovecraft – or “Howie’, as some fans affectionately call him. Rightly so, since he’s among a small handful of authors credited for shaping the very landscape of modern horror. Today, new readers continue to seek out the best HP Lovecraft books, losing themselves amid his cosmic worlds.

To this degree, I’m here to recommend you some of my favorite HP Lovecraft stories, based on my personal taste.

But first, let me share a few things about Howie, if only to address the elephant in the room.

  • Howie was closed-minded against people ethnically different from him. In fairness, this is partly because he was a student of the times, when science was trying to codify people through phrenology. However, Lovecraft was arguably more vocal in his dislike than he needed to be.
  • Lovecraft loathed writing for the pure sake of money. He considered authoring serialized fiction for pulp magazines to be a disgrace, something to be ashamed of. He thus came to the mindset that it was better to live off one’s inheritance, rather than perform vulgar labor.
  • Lovecraft was his own harshest critic. Half the time his friends and colleagues had to goad him into publishing a story, which he was often reluctant to do.
Best HP Lovecraft Books 2
Image credit: The Irish Times

A Tragic Life

Here’s some other Lovecraft trivia, of a more tragic nature:

  • Howie was born the only child to struggling middle-class parents, both of whom were eventually committed to insane asylums. He would then be raised by extended family.
  • Repeatedly afflicted by nervous breakdowns, Lovecraft was out of school as much as he was in. He was also reportedly an insomniac plagued by persistent nightmares.
  • Lovecraft aspired to be a scientist and read voraciously on his own. However, poverty and ill health killed his chances at a degree.
  • His marriage failed, mostly due to financial problems. On the plus side, his ex-wife described him as “an adequately excellent lover”.
  • Lovecraft sadly made very little money from his writing during his lifetime.
  • After his marriage was over, Lovecraft moved back home with his aunts, where he promptly fell ill with bowel cancer. He died shortly afterwards at the young age of 46.

Looking at the above, you can understand why Lovecraft’s disposition was so sour. Today, most doctors would see him as suffering from depression, if not severe anxiety. I think he’d have benefited greatly from modern medicine, and maybe a Patreon campaign to support his writing!

On the flip side, perhaps his dire circumstances were what shaped him to become among the greatest horror maestros ever. He was a visionary who went far beyond writing about typical boogies and spooks. Instead, he created malevolent gods of pure chaos and infinite darkness, weaved into magnificent cosmic worlds. In short, Lovecraft was a fictional horror genius.


What are some of the best HP Lovecraft books?

Lovecraft almost exclusively wrote short stories and novellas. A chunk of his work was also published posthumously, added into longer-length books and anthologies.

Here are a few of my favorite Lovecraft publications, in no particular order.

Please note I may be a little bit sketchy in my plot summaries. That’s because many of Lovecraft’s stories actually share very similar, recurring structures (i.e. Ordinary Joe travels to investigate a strange occurrence, discovers an ancient cosmic force, which soon makes him go gibbering mad). Ultimately, I believe the beauty of Lovecraft’s work lies in his admirable attention to descriptive detail, not his plots per se.


Pin this list on Pinterest!

The Call of Cthulhu and Other Weird Stories

Image credit: Penguin Classics

This collection includes The Call of Cthulhu, Lovecraft’s central work, and several other key stories in the Cthulhu Mythos. For those who might not know, Cthulhu is a cosmic entity of malevolence and mind-bending trans-dimensional chaos.

This book also includes a generous sampling of other stories published throughout Lovecraft’s career, including Dagon (one of his earliest) and The Haunter of the Dark (among his last). Most of these stories were originally scattered across different magazines.

Overall, I’d definitely recommend this to be one of the best HP Lovecraft books to start with!


The Shadow Over Innsmouth

Image credit: CreateSpace Independent Publishing Platform

The only novella published in actual book form during Lovecraft’s life. The Shadow Over Innsmouth is also part of the Cthulhu Mythos, though a branched variation of it.

Here’s a quick gist: a student investigates a mysterious New England seaport town. He starts to uncover the secrets behind some bizarre events, only to discover the existence of terrifying creatures.

The book has the closest thing to a “happy” ending you’ll get for a Lovecraft work, kinda. If you consider a reeling plunge into sheer cosmic horror uplifting.


The Whisperer in Darkness

Image credit: Blurb

This novella was originally published in installments in Weird Tales, and marks a proper turn to science fiction for Lovecraft. The plot revolves around a race of fungus-like aliens who are menacing humanity.

The alien race, called “Mi-go,” actually worship Cthulhu, which kinda says a lot about their horrific nature.


At the Mountains of Madness

Best H.P. Lovecraft Stories At the Mountains of Madness
Image credit: CreateSpace Independent Publishing Platform

Beloved by many fans, this is a Lovecraft novella that was originally published as installments in Astounding Stories. It’s a science fiction account of an ill-fated expedition to Antarctica, where explorers uncover a civilization of elder cosmic horror entities.

I’d easily consider this to be among the best HP Lovecraft stories ever.


The Case of Charles Dexter Ward

Best H.P. Lovecraft Books The Case of Charles Dexter Ward
Image credit: University of Tampa Press

Here is the founding work of Lovecraft’s ‘dream cycle’, where he dives head-first into a mixture of horror fantasy and occultism.

The book’s main character becomes obsessed with a distant relative, Joseph Curwen, who was an alleged wizard. He then tries to replicate Curwen’s magical experiments, only to accidentally unleash utter horror upon himself and those around him.


The Zombie Stories of H. P. Lovecraft

Best H.P. Lovecraft Stories The Zombie Stories
Image credit: Dover Publications

These zombie stories comprise Lovecraft’s “reanimator” mini-cycle, starting with his most famous work Herbert West – Reanimator, the basis for the cult 1985 film Re-Animator.

Many of these stories are, to put it bluntly, Lovecraft’s satirical take of Mary Shelley’s Frankenstein, although he does add a lot of his own spin to the genre.

The book also contains Cool Air and Pickman’s Model, two of my favorites. These stories carry on the theme of a mad scientist exploring new experimental frontiers, only to discover something nasty.

Love zombies? Check out our Best Zombie Books list!


The Complete Fiction of H. P. Lovecraft

Complete H.P. Lovecraft works
Image credit: Chartwell Books

If you’re tired of dawdling around with getting one novella at a time, try this release! It’s an (almost) complete compilation of H. P. Lovecraft major stories, clocking in at just over 1100 pages. Incidentally, that’s shorter than Stephen King‘s longest novel!

Yes, there are some editorial typos, and a few of his works are not included. But, seriously, no list of good HP Lovecraft books would be complete without this entry. This compilation also looks gorgeous on bookshelves.


More About Lovecraft’s Literary Style & Legacy

Lovecraft Themes
Image credit: Bitcultures

On the side, Lovecraft made most of his meager living as a ghostwriter and editor. His output of fiction is also evenly matched by his prolific correspondences. He was active pen-pals with many literary greats of his day, and also an avid United Amateur Press Association member.

Lovecraft’s literary influences include Edgar Allan Poe, whom he emulated with his mystery-detective stories, and Algernon Blackwood, whom he regarded as one of the best weird fiction writers of all-time.

Algernon Blackwood
Algernon Blackwood. Photo credit: warosu.org

Outside of literature, Lovecraft was no fan of technology. While most early 20th-century intellectuals embraced industrial progress, Lovecraft remained a romanticist at heart. He often held a dim view of humanity’s fate, believing we would one day surrender ourselves to machines. On hindsight, he wasn’t entirely wrong!

Lovecraft’s fiction can be broken into three stages, each building on the one before:

  • Macabre period (1905-1920): Sci-fi, fantasy, occult, Poe-type procedural narration.
  • Dream Cycle (1920-1927): Fantasy, aliens, and first appearance of the Necronomicon and Dreamlands.
  • Cthulhu Mythos (1925-1935): Cosmic horror which he is best known for.
Best HP Lovecraft Stories
Image credit: Radio Herejia

Lovecraft’s legacy cannot be understated. Before him, the genre was largely made up of Poe-esque mystery-ghost stories, Gothic tales inspired by Shelley’s Frankenstein, and a few Eastern European style vampire novels.

However, Lovecraft’s arrival greatly helped to expand the horror imagination to include ancient underground / oceanic civilizations, grotesque extraterrestrials, and eldritch occult lore. In essence, he elaborated on ideas by authors before him, which then led to his ushering in of cosmic horror,

Image credit: Estacao Nerd

Lovecraft is cited as a major influence by diverse authors such as Ramsey Campbell, Alan Moore, Junji Ito, William S. Burroughs, and Neil Gaiman. Most notably, Stephen King – the modern horror legend – heralds Lovecraft as his main literary influence, as discussed in his non-fiction thesis Danse Macabre.

So yes, even if Lovecraft was a bit of a poop, there’s no denying his tremendous influence and legacy. A true juggernaut of horror! It’s tantalizing to think about all the thrilling frontiers he might have conquered had he lived a little longer or not been crippled by unfortunate life circumstances.


Did I miss any of the best HP Lovecraft books? Email me with your suggestions!

376 Shares